Compare five material families

Choose a sheet material by considering the service environment, required strength, stiffness and weight, forming and joining route, surface requirements and supply condition together. The material family narrows the candidates; it cannot replace the exact grade, product standard and edition, condition or coating and supply requirements.

Choose by service conditions and forming needs

  • Compare the service environment with the required strength, stiffness and weight together; neither corrosion nor weight has a universal place in a fixed sequence.
  • Check the forming and joining route against the required shape, surface condition and protection after cutting or welding.
  • Identify the exact grade, product standard and edition, delivery condition or temper, and coating designation before agreeing the supply requirements.
  • Use the comparison below to narrow the candidates, then check the material documentation and representative trial evidence before release.

Material comparison

MaterialDensity (g/cm3)Typical useForming behaviourCorrosion behaviour
Carbon steel7.85Brackets, frames, guards and general fabricationPredictable springback; forms and welds easilyRusts when unprotected
Stainless steel 3047.93General-purpose parts that need corrosion resistanceHigher springback than mild steel; work hardens; galling riskGeneral corrosion resistance; 316 needs exposure-specific assessment
Stainless steel 3167.98Parts exposed to chloridesAs 304, with the same springback and galling cautionsMolybdenum addition for chloride exposure
Aluminium 5052 / 60612.705052 for marine and general forming; 6061 for machined structural partsDepends strongly on temper; 6061-T6 is much less formable than 5052-H32Natural oxide film; not the same as stainless resistance
Galvanized steel7.85Outdoor enclosures, ducts and guardsSteel core forms like mild steel; zinc coating can crack at tight bendsZinc protects the steel; cut edges and welds expose it
High-strength steel7.85Parts where strength-to-weight or wear resistance drives the designMore springback and higher tonnage; cracking risk at tight radiiDepends on grade and coating; strength alone does not make it corrosion resistant

The densities are approximate planning values for the listed materials, not certified batch values. Forming and corrosion columns are qualitative comparisons; they describe tendencies, not acceptance criteria. Copper and brass also appear in the weight calculator, but they are outside the five material families in this guide.

Reading the comparison

  • Density converts a blank size into a weight. It does not tell you whether the grade will bend without cracking.
  • Typical use is a starting point. The working environment and the forming route decide more than the material name.
  • Forming behaviour changes with temper, grade and grain direction. The same alloy can behave differently in two tempers.
  • Corrosion behaviour depends on exposure, coating condition and the state of cut edges and welds.

Use the sheet metal weight calculator for an initial mass estimate; its galvanized result excludes the zinc layer.

Carbon steel: Q235, S235JR and Q355, S355JR

Q235, S235JR, Q355 and S355JR are grade names to check under their respective product standards, editions and delivery conditions. Similar names or strength descriptions do not establish equivalence or permit substitution.

  • Density is 7.85 g/cm3; yield and tensile strength come from the mill certificate for the actual heat.
  • Springback rises with yield strength. The R/t ratio, the inside radius divided by thickness, is the first check when a bend cracks or opens up.
  • The minimum bend radius depends on grade, temper and grain direction. Mark the grain direction when a tight radius is critical, because a bend across the rolling direction behaves differently from one along it.
  • Laser cutting commonly uses oxygen assist; cite the ISO 9013 class with the material and thickness. Shearing leaves a burr that depends on blade clearance and edge condition.
  • Welding distortion is driven by heat input. Clean mill scale, oil and rust from the joint, and coat a welded part that will see moisture.

Stainless steel: 304 and 316

Stainless steel relies on a chromium-rich passive layer. Grade 304 (UNS S30400) is the general-purpose choice; grade 316 (UNS S31600) contains molybdenum and can offer greater chloride resistance than 304, subject to the actual exposure. The densities are 7.93 and 7.98 g/cm3, about 0.6 percent apart, so the grade changes the quoted weight as well as the corrosion behaviour.

  • Springback is higher than with mild steel. Work hardening means a second bend close to the first can behave differently from the first one.
  • Galling is a risk when stainless steel slides against stainless tooling. Protect the die surface and keep the tooling clean.
  • Laser cutting may use nitrogen assist; confirm gas, grade and edge requirements for the actual process. Inspect dross, burr and the heat-affected zone, and note that shearing can work-harden the cut edge.
  • Welding needs its own qualified procedure and consumables. Keep carbon steel contamination off the surface and remove heat tint where the part is visible.
  • Do not select 316 solely because chlorides or seawater are present. Both 304 and 316 can suffer localized corrosion; assess chloride concentration, temperature, crevices, exposure and cleaning with the material supplier or corrosion specialist.

Aluminium: 5052-H32 and 6061-T6

Aluminium is used where weight matters. Grade 5052 is the marine and general-forming choice, usually supplied as H32; grade 6061 is the machined structural choice, usually supplied as T6. Both have a density of 2.70 g/cm3, but the temper is part of the specification: 6061-T6 is much less formable than 5052-H32.

  • 5052-H32 suits general forming. A tight bend in 6061-T6 can crack, and the minimum radius depends on alloy, temper and grain direction.
  • Springback acts in every aluminium bend. Confirm the allowance with a trial part rather than assuming a steel value.
  • Bend lines across the grain and along the grain behave differently. Mark the grain direction when the radius is critical.
  • Laser cutting may use nitrogen assist; confirm gas, grade and edge requirements for the actual process. Deburr sheared edges because the soft material marks easily.
  • Remove the oxide layer before welding and keep steel tooling away from the aluminium surface. Confirm the filler and the procedure with the workshop.

Galvanized steel: Z275 coating

Interpret Z275 under the specified coating standard: the designation refers to 275 g/m2 total coating mass on both sides. The weight calculator uses the steel-core density of 7.85 g/cm3 and excludes the zinc layer. If coating-inclusive mass is needed, check the applicable coating information or weigh the part separately; do not enter coating mass per area as density or thickness.

  • The steel core forms like mild steel, but the zinc coating can crack or flake at a tight bend. A bend that exposes bare steel interrupts protection where water can collect.
  • Cutting interrupts the coating. Thermal-cut edge quality can be checked against the ISO 9013 class specified in the drawing or delivery requirements. Applying this standard to other cutting processes requires a separate agreement. Coating condition at the cut edge is a separate acceptance point.
  • Remove zinc from the joint before welding and protect the affected zone afterwards. Bare or burnt coating is a corrosion path, not a cosmetic issue.
  • Keep tooling clean so the coating is not scored during forming.
  • State the coating designation and the standard behind it on the purchase order. Z275 without a coating standard and a test method is an incomplete specification.

High-strength steel: specify the actual grade

High-strength steel covers different product families and strength levels; the term alone does not set a yield strength or forming limit. Specify the product standard, exact grade, thickness and delivery condition, then use the applicable declared properties and mill certificate.

  • Springback rises with yield strength and with the R/t ratio. A high-strength grade opens up more after the punch is released.
  • For comparable thickness, bend length, tooling and method, higher strength generally means higher bending force. Check the machine and tooling limits before scheduling the job.
  • Cracking risk rises at tight radii. Two grades inside the same range can need different bend radii, tooling and welding procedures.
  • A bend allowance taken from mild steel will not reproduce the same flat length. Confirm it with a trial part.
  • Laser cut parameters and the heat-affected zone deserve attention. Shearing requires more force than mild steel, and the cut edge matters if it will be bent afterwards.

Material release worksheet

Required fieldWhy it changes the decisionIf missing
Grade plus product standard and editionSimilar grade names do not prove interchangeable chemistry or propertiesHold substitution for engineering approval
Temper/condition, lot and measured thicknessFormability is not fixed by alloy name aloneRequest the certificate and retain actual readings
Rolling direction relative to bend lineDirection can affect cracking riskMark both directions on the trial blank
Required inside radius and unloaded angleThe process must achieve the specified geometryAgree geometry and trial method before release

Use a trial with the actual grade and condition to establish the forming response. For weight planning, choose a grade-specific density where available and note the value used. FAA chapter 4 discusses the material, radius and direction variables relevant to bending. [A1]

RFQ and processing checks

Send the current drawing and revision, the grade or alloy with its standard designation, the temper or coating designation, the thickness, the bend radius and grain direction, and the working environment. The mill certificate is the source for yield, tensile and elongation, not a generic table.

  • Grade and certificate: Q235, S235JR or Q355, S355JR, 304 or 316 with the UNS designation, 5052-H32 or 6061-T6, Z275 with its coating standard, or the high-strength grade.
  • Forming: check R/t, minimum flange and V-die opening. Use the tensile-strength input required by the tonnage calculator for an initial force estimate; bend deduction instead needs the defined geometry and applicable unfolding assumptions, checked against a trial in the production material.
  • Thermal cutting: state the agreed ISO 9013 class with the material and thickness. Using this reference for other cutting processes requires a separate agreement. On galvanized sheet keep the coating condition separate from the cut class.
  • Welding and protection: confirm the procedure and consumable, remove zinc or oxide where required, and specify coating repair on cut edges and welds.
  • Weight and handling: use the correct density. The galvanized result excludes the zinc layer, and 304 versus 316 changes the weight by about 0.6 percent.

For the geometry and process checks, continue with the bending guide; for identified specimens and measurement records, use the trial-bend procedure.

Confirm the material for the order

Use the density table for initial weight planning. Confirm the exact grade, condition and required properties from the product specification and material certificate for the batch.

Check standard identities in the standards index; an index entry is not proof that a material or batch conforms.