Compare both routes at the same accepted output
The calculator compares annual cost for the same accepted-part quantity, product mix and period. It does not estimate robot cycle time or turn theoretical extra output into profit. Accepted parts exclude rejects, and each route must carry its own programming, changeover, inspection, replenishment, stop and recovery labour.
- Incremental installed investment is the difference between the two complete installed routes, not just the robot or press-brake purchase price.
- Paid labour hours include every paid hour required by that route; labour rates are the corresponding cost per paid hour.
- Other annual costs cover items such as maintenance, energy, consumables, software and support without duplicating labour or installed investment.
- Lower and higher demand scenarios are independent inputs. The calculator applies no automatic percentage multiplier.
- Accepted-part quantity is a positive whole number. Other numeric inputs may be zero and are limited to 1000000000000; these are software limits, not production or investment guidance.
Read annual cost, unit cost and simple payback
Annual cost equals paid labour hours multiplied by the labour rate, plus other annual costs. Annual net benefit is manual annual cost minus robot-route annual cost. Unit cost divides each annual route cost by the same accepted-part quantity. Simple payback divides positive incremental investment by positive annual net benefit; zero or negative benefit and zero incremental investment return an explicit not-applicable state.
This is a static, undiscounted comparison. It excludes extra output value, financing, tax, depreciation and residual value. A positive result is only as reliable as the production and cost assumptions entered.
Worked example with hypothetical inputs
Hypothetical inputs in one currency: incremental investment I = 75000, manual labour rate Rm = 18 and robot-route labour rate Rr = 20. The table shows the remaining inputs and the calculated results. These values demonstrate the arithmetic only and are not recommended inputs.
| Input or result | Manual route | Robot route |
|---|---|---|
| Accepted parts per year Q | 12000 | 12000 |
| Paid labour hours Hm / Hr | 2400 | 1000 |
| Other annual costs Om / Or | 6000 | 4000 |
| Annual cost Cm / Cr | 49200 | 24000 |
| Cost per accepted part Um / Ur | 4.10 | 2.00 |
Annual net benefit B = 49200 − 24000 = 25200. Simple payback P = 75000 ÷ 25200 = 2.98 years, rounded only for display. Check each substitution against your own inputs before using the comparison.
Verify the production route before comparing investment
Use the bending automation selection guide to verify part handling, gripping, changeovers and accepted-output measurement, then review the robotic bending cell equipment and configuration scope. Cost arithmetic cannot establish whether a part family is suitable for automation.
Use the planned scenario in an equipment discussion
The planned-scenario handoff records your inputs and calculated comparison as optional context for a technical discussion. It is not a factory trial, a quotation or a guaranteed return, and completing the calculator is not required before contacting us.